CONVEYANCE AND ASSIGNMENT THE DISTINCTION
ONCE THERE IS A DEED OF ASSIGNMENT EXECUTED BY THE LESSOR IN FAVOUR OF THE LESSEES CAN THERE BE DEEMED CONVEYANCE? Why am I writing this blog? You must be wondering! No noting without cause. Nowadays, in the name of redevelopment societies are collecting huge funds like 20-30 lakhs for Deemed Conveyance. But I am saying it’s wrong? The answer is this society already had a Deed of Assignment executed and registered in its name way back in 1970s. Now this is connivance or illiteracy of the committee that depends on documentary evidence. But this is no less serious offense. Why? It amounts to embezzlement of society funds by way of misrepresentation and fraud. ANALYSIS Let us analyse the question herein is to ascertain as to whether the deed in question is a deed of assignment of lease hold rights. Article 63 of Schedule 1-B of the Indian Stamp Act or would be an outright sale so as to be termed as ‘Conveyance” and would be covered by Article 23 of Schedule 1-B of the Indian Stamp Act. The word ‘sale’ has not been defined under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899. Section 2 (10) of the Act defines “Conveyance” as including a conveyance on sale and every instrument by which property, whether movable or immovable property is transferred inter vivos and which is not otherwise specifically provided for by Schedule 1-A or Schedule 1-B, as the case may be. Now let us see the difference in common parlance: Deed of Assignment: This document transfers interest in property from one person or entity to another. Purpose: It’s used when someone wants to transfer their interest in a property to someone else, such as in property sales or lease assignments. Nature of Transfer: It involves transferring existing property rights, not creating new ones. The Transfer is conditional subject to the terms of Lease Agreement and in case of breach the Lessor/Owner steps in. Execution: It requires the consent and signature of the person or entity giving up their rights. Stamp Duty and Registration: Depending on local laws, it may or may need to be stamped and registered with the land authority. Deed of Conveyance: This document transfers property ownership from a seller to a buyer. Purpose: Confirming Agreement for Sale to establish the buyer’s legal ownership. Nature of Transfer: It creates new property ownership and rights, transferring everything about the property to the new owner. Execution: Both the seller and the buyer must sign it. Requires to be stamped and registered mandatorily. Registration: It typically needs to be registered to show the change in property ownership. In short, Deeds of Assignment transfer existing property rights, while Deeds of Conveyance create new property rights and prove ownership. The word ‘Sale” has been defined under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 which reads as under:- “Sale is a transfer of ownership in exchange for a price paid or promised or part-paid and part-promised.” “Lease” has been defined under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and also in sub-section (16) of Section 2 of the Stamp Act, 1899 which […]
Read moreMAHARASHTRA CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY ACT LACUNAE ABUSE OF POWER AN ANALYSIS AND SUGGESTIONS
“Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a men’s character, give him power.” Said Abraham Lincoln This aptly applies to the Managing Committee of a society. Once the power comes neighbor becomes your Master. There are many incidents where the committee manipulates bills and contracts, and even in redevelopment cases three honorary office bearers Secretary, Chairman, and Treasurer have weightage in the finalization of the deal. We see litigations and stalling of projects of a housing society. Human tendency is such that they think of self-gain, instead of taking care and executing responsibilities that they have taken with utmost care and truthfulness. Corrupt minds see financial benefits in every deal. They forget that while doing this they prejudice the property and interests of other flat members. Election: 1 With the new election rules, an election is held similarly to the way in which how elections are held in any Assembly and Parliament. Cartel is formed and elections are won. It has killed the neighborhood’s love, respect, and honor. One family and one flat provision are also violated royally. Even if distant relatives or cousins have a cartel. This creates a monopoly in management. Suggestion: Like Multi Co-operative society, provide that same member or any other joint member from one flat cannot contest the consecutive election. The flat owners/member must take a break or drop out from the next election to give an opportunity to other flat owners/members. So, after serving for 5 years the said member/flat owner cannot contest election for immediate subsequent another term. This will reduce the monopoly of a few flat owners and their families, and their friends. For the convenience of the readers and lawmakers reproduced below is the provision of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act,2002 below which restricts reelection after two terms. Prohibition to hold the office of chairperson or president or vice chairperson or vice president in certain cases (1) No member of a board shall be eligible to be elected as the chairperson or president or vice-chairperson or vice-president of a multi-state cooperative society if such member is a Minister in the Central Government or a State Government. (2) No member of a board shall be eligible to be elected as the chairperson or president of a multi-state cooperative society, after he has held the office as such during two consecutive terms, whether full or part: Provided that a member who has ceased to hold the office of the chairperson or president continuously for one full term shall again be eligible for election to the office as such. Explanation:- where any member holding the office of the chairperson or president at the commencement of this Act is against elected to that office after such commencement, he shall for the purpose of this section, be deemed to have held office for one term before such election. Proposed Suggestion : A similar principle must be applied to the housing society. A.2 A Managing Committee was disqualified for 5 years, and an administrator was appointed. Managing Committee manages to suppress the facts from members of the society and manages that the […]
Read moreCAN THE COOPERATIVE SOCIETY COMMITTEE BLOCK ACCESS TO THE COMMON TERRACE?
This is a very common dispute. Most of the time Committee decides on whims and fancies. Which is not permissible. If any untoward incident like a fire happens Managing Committee shall be liable for culpability. To start the discussion first we must know the provisions of Byelaws. When Terrace is a common area as per the official plan and agreement with promoter builders it’s a joint and several ownerships. Every society especially as we are discussing housing society is governed by Model Byelaws. They are framed under the provisions of the Maharashtra Cooperative Society Act,1960 which is a Central Act. Now let us see the provisions of the model bye-laws. 3 xxi. “Open terraces” means terraces which are otherwise not in the exclusive possession of any of the Members. 3 xxii “Common Areas and Facilities” means a.the land on which the building is located; b. the foundations, columns, girders, beams, supports, main walls,roofs, halls, corridors, lobbies, stair-ways, lifts / escalators , fire escapes and entrances and exits of the building; c. the basements, cellars, yards, gardens, parking areas undemarcated / demarcated parking slots, and storage spaces; d. the premises for the lodging of janitors or persons employed for the management of the property; e. installations of central services such as power, light, gas, water storage and water heating, water harvesting, pump houses, refrigeration, air conditioning, generators, roof top solar devices, common antennas and mass communication and data sharing devices, f.the elevators, tanks, pumps, motors, fans, compressors, ducts and in general all apparatus and installations existing for common use; g. such community and commercial facilities as may have been provided for; h. all other parts of the property necessary or convenient to its existence, maintenance and safety or normally in common use; Under Bylaw 67 (a) (xiv) members are paying for the maintenance of the terrace being a common facility. What society can do is to, regulate permission to use for functions under bye-law 168. Now moving further a law has been passed in Maharashtra namely the Prevention of Fire and Life Safety Measure Act,2016. Under this law, it’s the owner’s responsibility to keep up fire safety measures. In a matter before the division bench Once a person agrees to the sale/ purchase of a floor in a property, they bind themselves to joint access to common areas, its use, and enjoyment by way of such an agreement. Any obstruction caused that results in deprivation of essential amenities that are water, electricity etc. cannot be permitted and requires immediate intervention to rectify the situation as they have a direct bearing on the right to life of a human” All residents must have access to common areas’ | Delhi News – Times of India (indiatimes.com) In yet another case of Tasneem Dhariwala Bombay High Court Division Bench of Justice S.C Dhamadhikari and Justice Gautam Patel in identical facts held, Such parties cannot be given any discretionary and equitable relief, much less [allowed] to obstruct a public body from performing the statutory duties and ensuring that there is free access to all persons to an area called terrace and, particularly, to take care […]
Read more